Peri News / South Korea
Store music: Korean court considers gains received by headquarters
Two payment orders were overturned and remanded. The reported principle requires courts to establish headquarters' actual gains for restitution of unjust enrichment.

According to Chosunbiz, South Korea's Supreme Court has overturned and remanded two decisions ordering payments by companies that arranged music services for retail networks. The reported principle concerns restitution for unjust enrichment: signing a contract with a provider or facilitating playback does not, by itself, establish that headquarters received an economic benefit. The publisher identifies the article as an AI translation; the full judgments have not been consulted.
Franchisees and dealers played tracks without authorization covering copyright holders' public performance rights. The report does not specify whether those rights concerned compositions or sound recordings. The first overturned decision ordered the company heading a tire sales and replacement network to pay 9,424,157 South Korean won to a music copyright management organization; the second ordered an electronics supplier to pay 40,188,000 South Korean won. The cases were remanded to the Seoul Central District Court and the Seoul High Court, respectively. The article describes the first proceeding as a damages action but does not clarify how the reasoning on restitution for unjust enrichment affects the damages claim.
According to the report, the Court held that increases in sales or franchise numbers attributable to music should not be presumed. In the electronics case, the mere possibility of dividends from a subsidiary did not establish that its profits had accrued to the parent, since they are separate legal entities. On remand, courts will examine any payments for music services and commercial benefits actually received by the defendant companies. The newspaper explains that this separate assessment of enrichment does not exempt store operators from liability for infringing public performance rights.
Sources
- Supreme Court says franchise headquarters owe royalties only with proven gain - CHOSUNBIZbiz.chosun.com — 15 November 2026
