Peri News / European Union
EU court adviser: social networks requiring data for commercial use should not claim to be free (non-binding opinion)
A non-binding opinion proposes treating personal data as possible consideration for digital services, with implications for claims that services are free. The court has yet to rule.

Federprivacy, in its article “Per l’UE i social network non sono gratis: gli utenti li pagano con i propri dati personali”, reports that Laila Medina, Advocate General at the Court of Justice of the European Union, proposes recognising personal data as a possible form of payment for a digital service. According to the report, the opinion was delivered on 19 November 2026 in Case C-643/25, concerning the meaning of payment under EU unfair commercial practices rules. The opinion is non-binding and the court has yet to rule. The opinion itself has not been consulted directly, so this account remains limited to the journalistic report.
The dispute concerns the statement “Facebook is and will remain free”, used on the registration page in February 2015. According to Federprivacy, a German consumer association challenged it, arguing that users paid through their personal data and consent to its commercial exploitation. The question reached the court following a referral from the Bundesgerichtshof, Germany’s Federal Court of Justice. Under the interpretation attributed to the Advocate General, payment can take non-monetary forms, provided it has economic value and is linked to the service received. A service should therefore not be presented as free when it requires personal data for commercial purposes; processing limited to what is necessary to provide the service or comply with legal obligations falls outside that restriction.
Federprivacy also reports that the proposal, based on Directive 2005/29/EC on unfair commercial practices, distinguishes consumer protection from data protection rules. Recognising data as possible consideration would not automatically make processing lawful or replace the safeguards of the General Data Protection Regulation (GDPR), including transparency, a legal basis and freely given consent. Any implications for platforms’ claims that their services are free depend on the court’s future ruling.
